The Paradox of Balance
At In Good Company this month, July 2025, we are exploring the theme of balance. At first glance, balance appears a much-admired and sought-after state; think work-life balance, emotional balance, dietary diet, even balanced views. The ideal of a balanced life is almost assumed, something we take for granted without question. However, for most of us, aspiring to this requires great effort and remains a distant, unreachable, and unrealisable horizon. Put bluntly, a life in perfect alignment may sound appealing, but is it real or realistic? Is balance a state we arrive at or rather an attunement to an ongoing, changing process?
What is Balance, really?
When I consider the meaning of the word balance, images that spring to mind include old-fashioned weighing scales, a ballet dancer mid-pirouette, a tightrope walker teetering on a rope. Each of these examples requires an ongoing process of sensitivity, involving, at times, subtle adjustments. The paradox is that balance includes imbalance. It might be better described as Balancing. Balance, in lived experience, is a momentary state arising within an ongoing process of adaptive feedback: A balancing act.
Living Systems balance
Environmental scientist and futurist James Lovelock proposed that earth is a self-regulating organism. The entirety of diverse living organisms, from bacteria to whales, algae to oaks, as well as inorganic matter like viruses, the air we breathe, oceans and land all interact and affect the Earth’s climate and biosphere. A butterfly flaps its wings in Tokyo and a storm unfolds in California. Regardless of scale, all living systems, whether planetary or personal, contribute to the regulatory balance we depend on for survival. Our planet, within the wider universe, is a vast interdependent system providing a habitable biosphere of air, sea, and soil.
As humans we too self-regulate. Through the process of homeostasis, our bodies maintain essential life functions such as optimal temperature, blood sugar levels and water content. Nevertheless, our ability to maintain states of equilibrium is sustained by the environments we inhabit through adaptive processes of ongoing feedback. Balancing.
We Inter-are with the Earth.
Vietnamese Zen teacher Thich Nhat Hanh taught that we ‘inter-are’ with the Earth. Our bodies are not apart from nature, or reducible to a part of nature, but rather they are a thread in the weave of the wider natural ecology. For example, humans are composed of mostly water along with nutrients and elements that make up the natural world. We all live in symbiotic relationship with this planet. For example, right now take a moment to notice that your breath is happening … With each inhalation your body is taking in oxygen produced by trees and tiny pink plankton in the oceans… With each exhalation, your body is returning that air back to the trees and oceans …
Environmental activist and systems thinker Joanna Macy says,
‘To be alive in this beautiful, self-organising universe – to participate in the dance of life with senses to perceive it, lungs that breathe it, organs that draw nourishment from it -is a wonder beyond words.’
Sadly, our existence within this delicate balance is under threat. We now live in an epoch, that many call the Anthropocene – The Age of Humans. For the first time in human history, our biosphere composed of the Earth’s climate and geology is being significantly reshaped by human activity. Over extraction and abuse of resources such as oil, gas, coal, minerals and forests are damaging the fragile conditions for life.
The Imbalance of Modern Life
As our earth systems are imbalanced, so are our human systems. The pace of life in modern industrialised societies is frenzied. Speed is king. Technology advances at a dizzying pace, dragging our nervous systems along with it. Many of us struggle. Always connected but rarely present. Message. Check. Repeat. Scroll. Repeat. The question is: Are we using our phones, or are they using us? Author Johann Hari warns in his book Stolen Focus that mobile phones are designed to be addictive. In this way corporations can harvest our data for profit: the attention economy.
The advertising and media industries compete for our attention too. Grooming us into a sense of lack and insufficiency. We are never enough. We never have enough. We are encouraged to buy more, own more, become more, to reach unreachable ideals. The beautiful house. The exotic holidays. The swish car. The perfect body. The desirable personal fashion style. The good life! Consumerist values have come to dominate the lives we live, as well as those we can imagine. Happiness is commodified with the promise that our sadness can be eradicated. This cultural phenomenon is the subject of Adam Curtis’s astute and informative documentary ‘The Century of the Self’. Worth viewing to better understand how we got here.
‘The world is too much with us; late and soon,
Getting and spending, we lay waste our powers’
William Wordsworth (1770-1850)
Many of us work harder and harder, to buy more, to keep up with, the ‘happy’ life. Byung-Chul Han captures this in his book ‘The Burn Out Society’. Just as our planet is plagued by floods, fires, genocides and war, we are plagued by insomnia, anxiety, stress, migraines, digestive issues, chronic fatigue, allergies and loneliness. Another way of describing this is Affluenza, the sickness of the global north.
‘When it becomes all-consuming, speed is the ultimate defense, the antidote to stopping and really looking. If we really saw what we were doing and who we had become, we feel we might not survive the stopping and the accompanying self-appraisal. So we don’t stop, and the faster we go, the harder it becomes to stop.’
The Mirage of Ideal Balance, Bursting the Bubble
The relentlessness of modern life and the realisation that material wealth doesn’t guarantee happiness leads many of us to seek alternatives. Hence the popularity of mindfulness meditation. Learning to meditate is a radical reclamation of our attention. A form of psychological self-defence.
In meditation, we invest time strengthening our internal resources and values. We investigate and recognise how the demands of material pursuits undermine our well-being and that of the planet.
‘…as slaves to speed, we start to lose sight of family members, especially children, or those who are ill or infirm, who are not flying through the world as quickly and determinedly as we are. Just as seriously, we begin to leave behind the parts of our own selves that limp a little, the vulnerabilities that actually give us colour and character. We forget that our sanity is dependent on a relationship with longer, more patient cycles extending beyond the urgencies and madness…’ David Whyte
We learn, sometimes painfully, to slow down. To simplify the conditions necessary for well-being. To engage in a process of balancing the different aspects of our lives – relationships, family, work, health and spiritual interests, in ways that support well-being. Over time, we cultivate an inner reservoir of sustenance, sufficiency, balance and contentment.
And it doesn’t cost anything!
However, even mindfulness practice is not immune to the reach of consumer culture. It can be repackaged as yet another self-improvement project. We hope that mindfulness is a magic pill that will solve life once and for all. That we will find perfect balance and inner peace. When, inevitably, that doesn’t happen, we blame ourselves. We take imbalance as a personal failing, despairing that mindfulness doesn’t ‘work’. The reality is that unchanging balance doesn’t exist. It’s a collective mirage. I take solace in the words of meditation/yoga teacher Micheal Stone:
‘By committing to a practice of being quiet, waking up the intelligence of the body, and listening and communicating as best I can, I try to embody the teachings…in everything I do. This kind of commitment always gets me in trouble because I continually fail. Failing becomes practice.’
Sitting in meditation, particularly longer periods of 30-60 minutes, is a training in receiving all experiences. In longer practice, we build our capacity to stay. To experience both the pleasant and unpleasant with curiosity. In this way we begin to see that our well-being doesn’t depend on circumstances. We develop equanimity. Described by meditation teacher Christina Feldman as:
‘…not a state but a relational way of being with life that rests on a profound understanding of the intrinsic nature of change, unpredictable and non self, that is at the heart of all experience.’
We develop poise within the highs and lows of life; praise and blame, loss and gain, good reputation and ‘bad’. We find balance through imbalance, adapt, adjust and respond to the moment-to-moment changing nature of experience. We might bend under the force of change but we rebound. We are affected but not swept away.
A Zen master was once asked, “What is the secret of your equanimity? He answered, “Complete unrestricted co-operation with the unavoidable”.
Imbalance as opportunity
When we grow our capacity to include all of life, even the difficult, we uncover endless opportunities for growth. We live in the poet Alison Luterman’s words, ‘as large a life as possible. It’s precisely in our moments of disorientation, uncertainty and imbalance, that something new can emerge. German poet Rainer Marie Rilke speaks to this when he says,
‘If only we arrange our life according to that principle which counsels us that we must always hold to the difficult, then that which now still seems to us the most alien will become what we most trust and find most faithful.’
What if, life isn’t a problem to be solved, a state of perfect balance to be attained, but a dynamic, ever-changing, experience to be lived? How might this understanding change the ways in which we meet life’s highs and lows? We will experience heartbreak, injustice, overwhelm and pain. We are human after all. How might our practice support us to cultivate greater flexibility, adaptivity and kindness in the face of life’s messiness. To stay connected to what’s alive, humble and awake?