Even This: Trust as a Radical Act

by Rosalie Dores on 14th April 2025

I’ve been reflecting on trust—what it really means in uncertain times, and how we find it in our bones.

‘Que sera, sera. Whatever will be, will be. The futures not ours to see. Que sera, sera.’

It’s hard to trust

It’s hard to trust, to relax and feel secure when the basic human needs for shelter, food and healthcare are premised on how much money one has.  Unfortunately, this is the position of multitudes in the global south and many in the financially wealthy global north. In the UK, where I live, one of the richest countries in the world, neo-liberal market economics has resulted in homelessness and food banks becoming commonplace. I know this is true in Europe and the US too.

Each day brings news of radical changes on our planet. Extinctions, environmental disasters and abuses of technological, political and economic power. Conspiracy theorists grasp at narratives of certainty. False ‘facts’ and deepfakes corrode the moral fabric of society. In the midst of all this, in what do we place our trust?

For the purposes of this article I am speaking to people ‘privileged enough’ to have a home, food, healthcare, relative safety, time to meditate and explore their experience of trust. And yet, even with basic needs in place, one cannot avoid the fact that life is innately insecure.

Conditional Trust

For many people, what is called trust is simply an effort to secure a picture of the world that is based on a desire for comfort and safety. For those privileged enough to do so, security is sought in health regimes, relationships, house purchases and growing bank accounts. People work long hours to ensure that these aspects of life are in place. These measures to take care of oneself and loved ones are important, even prudent. However, they offer a form of security that is based on conditions being a certain way.

Perhaps the unceasing activity, distractedness and consumerism that epitomises cultures of the global north is at heart an avoidance of the reality of uncertainty. An attempt to shore up against the uncontrollability of things. We know deep in our bones that all things are impermanent. That life is uncertain. That death will come.

What if recognising the potential freedom means that I can’t hold all the patches in place

Insight Dialogue teacher Gregory Kramer puts it this way:

‘Right now, each of us in our own way, have it patched together – with varying degrees of success … Isn’t that the nature of it? I’ll patch it, and then the boat starts to leak over there … It’s an old boat, guys. We can patch it together with really comfortable chairs in the living room. We can patch it together with our favourite foods. We can patch it together with our friends. We can patch it together with our meditation practices that soothe. We can patch it together with our exercise sessions or our therapist … What if recognising the potential freedom means that I can’t hold all the patches all in place?’

In what does one trust?

If one accepts that life cannot be made secure by controlling external conditions, then in what does one trust?

trust without doubt is a kind of fundamentalism

The dictionary defines trust as ‘a firm belief in the reliability, truth, or ability of someone or something.’ I question the part about a firm belief. It seems to me that doubt is a pre-requisite of trust. Trust is required precisely because life, people, situations are uncertain. I have to keep evoking trust, in the face of uncertainty and not knowing. For let’s face it, trust without doubt is a form of fundamentalism.

An Inner Compass

Danish philosopher Kierkegaard describes trust as a ‘leap of faith’. A leap into the unknown. We don’t know how things will turn out but we know that a step needs to be taken. This is trust in ‘something’ that is not bound by the limits of reason and logic. It is not a blind, heedless leap, but the willingness to face the unknown with courage and confidence. The 19th century hermit poet Emily Dickinson describes this well when she says,’ The sailor cannot see the north/but knows the needle can.’ David Whyte also speaks to this in a poem from his book ‘Crossing the Unknown Sea: Work as a Pilgrimage of Identity’:

‘But still, on the ocean, there is no path

Only the needles trembling dance north

…

Here, near at hand

In the centre of your body,

The rose-fire

Of the compass

Blossoming

With direction.’

This kind of trust is embodied and enacted through how you live, in what you do. Whether this is entering or leaving a new job, relationship or country. Or how you respond to the inevitable ‘slings and arrows of outrageous fortune.’ The gain and loss, praise and blame, fame and disrepute, pleasure and pain that are an inevitable part of life.

Cultivating Trust

It is a trust that’s not dependent on external conditions being a particular way. Known. A trust that can be cultivated, developed and strengthened through a meditative practice and path. It evolves and matures through continuity of practice. The willingness to show up day after day, year after year. To stay present with the pleasant and unpleasant, the welcome and unwelcome in ourselves and our lives.

The very experiences one might be prone to reject become grist for the mill. Learned certainties and habits of perspective about which experiences are acceptable or not are suspended. One learns that staying with difficulty can  strengthen us, season us into maturity. Learning to include and navigate our difficulties internally builds confidence. One finds that one can rely on oneself even when things are tough. This is unconditional trust.  A trust that one can depend on.

The teacher Siddharta Gotoma, otherwise know as Buddha(someone who has woken up) is reported to have said,

‘We are indeed our own protection,

We are indeed our own secure abiding;

How could it be otherwise?

So with due care we attend to ourselves.

Dhammpada V.380

This is not a treatise on hyper individualism, but the recognition that we make the journey into and out of this life alone. We will navigate the time in between, the births, deaths, challenges and achievements, hopefully in the company of friends and family, but ultimately alone. One needs to be able to rely on oneself.

Radical Trust

Trust is implicit in the experience of being human. One trusts that one will wake up in the morning. That a lifted foot will find ground. That the body knows when to eat, how to breathe. It’s so commonplace that its invisible. At the same time, trust can be so painful and difficult. Particularly when what we call trust is in fact an investment in our desires, hopes and expectations of others and life to be fulfilled. Of course we will feel betrayed when things don’t go our way. And friends, things won’t go ‘our way.’

Part of maturing as a human being is to be painfully leavened by the reality that being born, we age, sicken and die and so too does everyone else. Everyone that we love. To access trust in the midst of this is a radical act. It get’s to the existential roots, reality of things. It’s ultimately liberating. The poet Rilke speaks to this quality of trust in his epic poem, The Man Watching. In the poem Rilke draws on the biblical story of Jacob being physically wrestled by an angel:

Whoever was beaten by this Angel
(who often simply declined the fight)
went away proud and strengthened
and great from that harsh hand,
that kneaded him as if to change his shape.
Winning does not tempt that man.
This is how he grows: by being defeated, decisively,
by constantly greater beings.

–Translated by Robert Bly

This poem is a guide and inspiration for me. When things are difficult, challenging, painful. How do I let myself be defeated. How do I trust, even this…This is the kind of trust I aspire to—the trust that comes not from victory, but from being reshaped by challenge. The trust that grows when I stop fighting and start listening to what life is asking of me.

An Inner Crucible

In our meditative practice and path we craft an inner crucible. A crucible that is robust enough to digest, process and transform even the heaviest lead into the gold of realisation and greater freedom. For we don’t want to die like the musk deer in the Hindu Upanishads, who smells the most beautiful scent in the air. She searches high and low, travelling the world searching for another whiff of this scent.

‘She ended up devoting her entire life to her search and one day fell exhausted onto the forest floor.  As she fell one of her horns pierced her own belly.  Suddenly the air was overwhelmingly flooded with this divine heavenly scent.  After a lifetime of searching, in the presence of the final moments of her precious life she realized the scent was coming from her, the whole time.’

   The scent was coming from her, the whole time

Trust is not something to grasp, but something to rest into. Like the scent that was always within the deer. Like the body of water that holds us when we lift our feet. Trust is both an innate capacity and a quality that can be cultivated.

I’d love to hear how you relate to trust, especially in times of change or doubt. Let’s keep this conversation alive. You might join me and the community at In Good Company as we contemplate trust this month, April.

 

Image: Letting Go by Rosalie Dores

One thought on “Even This: Trust as a Radical Act”

  1. You have just lead me in a mindfulness practice. Thank you for that. We can only trust in the earth, the energy of the universe and what is present right now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *